Savita's Top Ten Favourite Movies that were made from books:
I love books and I love films, but I’ve always worried when a favourite book has been made into a film. Invariably, I will think that it can never be as good as the book, and usually I’m right. The book is always better than the film, but that’s not to say that there haven’t been good movies that have been inspired by a book. I’ve probably missed out some really good movies that were made from books, but this is a list of my favourite movies that were made from books that I’ve read:
1. The Godfather
For me, the film version was far better than the book. I watched it again recently and still loved it.
2. The Lord of the Rings
The books are brilliant – I’ve been reading and re-reading them since I was twelve, but the film versions are fantastic if they are considered separately from the books.
3. The Railway Children
A classic book and a classic film that I grew up with.
4. Holes
My son introduced me to Louis Sachar, and I’m so glad he did.
5. I am Legend
I’m a Will Smith fan and this probably isn’t his best film, but I really enjoyed it. I’m still reading the book – in daylight hours only though!
6. Anna Karenina
I read this in my teens and I loved it. I think the film is being remade this year, but the version that I loved was with Vivien Leigh as the doomed Anna.
7. Gone With the Wind
This was such a classic in our home when I was growing up – the book and the film, but I do love the film version of the book with Clark Gable and Vivien Leigh. I’m not sure I would ever want to see a remake of it with anyone else.
8. Rebecca
Another book I read in my teens and which I loved. The film version I loved was Alfred Hitchcock’s black and white thriller with Laurence Olivier and Joan Fontaine.
9. Silence of the Lambs
I enjoyed the book, but for me the film version was utterly brilliant! Anthony Hopkins was chillingly inspired as Hannibal Lector, and Jodie Foster was perfect as the young FBI agent.
10. To Kill a Mockingbird
I love both the book and the film. Gregory Peck was utterly brilliant as Atticus Finch.
As I was doing this list lots of other films came to mind –some of them I had read as books and others that I hadn’t. I’m sure every one of your readers would come up with a very different list – and I would probably slap my forehead and think – How could I have forgotten that! So I would be very interested if your readers post their top ten list of favourite movies that were made from books in the comments section.
http://twitter.com/savitakalhan

The Long Weekend:
Sam knows that he and his friend Lloyd made a colossal mistake when they accepted the ride home. They have ended up in a dark mansion in the middle of nowhere with man who means to harm them. But Sam doesn't know how to get them out. They were trapped, then separated. Now they are alone. Will either of them get out alive? This gripping and hypnotic thriller will have you reading late into the night.
Book Giveaway:
I have a copy of The Long Weekend for giveaway. Savita shared her top ten movie that have been made from books and asked to know ours. To enter the giveaway just leave a comment with at least one of your favorite book to movie adaptations.
Open Internationally
Make sure there is a way for me to contact you if you win
Ends 2/23
One of my favorite book to movie adaptation is the entire Lord of the Rings trilogy - wonderfully done and one of the few movies that are as good as the books.
ReplyDeleterickimc[at]aol[dot]com
Stephen Kings "Stand by Me" is one of my favorites! Oh and "Schindler's List" of course!!
ReplyDeletedanaan at gmx dot at
I love any and all of the Poirot series by Agatha Christie to movies. I think David Suchet does him perfectly down to the mustache.
ReplyDeletebittenbooks at gmail dot com
The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy. of course the books are waaaaay better than the film. But I love the books so the film just gave me a reason to talk about the books with anyone who would listen! and it's a great way to get a quick dose of the books, when I don't actually have time to sit and read them all. (cause once i start reading them i don't want to put them down):)
ReplyDeleteI also love The Last Unicorn, however I haven't been able to read the book yet, but it is one of my favorite films, that I only found out recently was adapted from a book.
aimeelavalle@gmail.com
my favourite adaption is definitely fight club,but i also love the virgin suicides.
ReplyDeletestrandedhero(at)gmail(dot)com
The Firm is the first one that came to mind.
ReplyDeletelkish77123 at gmail dot com
Pride & Prejudice. The newest one!!
ReplyDeleteJudy
magnolias_1[at)msn[dot}com
I think I like The Lion The Witch and The Wardrobe the best.
ReplyDeleteStephanie
thegirlonfire27 at gmail dot com
I would say Lord of the Rings, and the Harry Potter movies.
ReplyDeleteLolawid
widsfam7@digis.net
Coraline. Loved it.
ReplyDeleteVivien
deadtossedwaves at gmail dot com
I love Pride & Prejudice movie with Keira! And of course all movies about Harry Potter! Or Lors of the Rings... yay... I can not choose only one book-into-movie...
ReplyDeleteThank you for this giveaway!
sykorova.p@gmail.com
I love what everyone has said and agree with all of them another is The Silence of the Lambs.
ReplyDeleteObviously an outstanding job on that one.
frellathon(at)gmail(dot)com
My favorite is Twilight and Harry Potter series.
ReplyDeleteannabell_lee_dk (at) yahoo.com
I think a great movie adaptation was the Notebook by Nicholas Sparks was amazing
ReplyDeletekristen_babygurl@hotmail.com
I loved The Notebook and the Time Traveler's Wife. I'm excited for I Am Number Four to be coming out, that looks quite good and Red Riding Hood xD.
ReplyDeletebreakkanamexd [@] aol [.] com
Thanks for hosting this giveaway. It has been a while since I read the book, but one of my favorite book to movie adaptations is Jim Carroll's The Basketball Diaries.
ReplyDeleteactinupwb at gmail.com
I'm usually very critical of movies made from books. There's a family joke about my throwing pop corn at the screen. But there are a few, I've enjoyed. The Harry Potter movies are well done. Narnia. I thought the movie How to Train Your Dragon was better than the book. But I think my all time favorite movie based on a book is To Kill a Mockingbird. (Oh, and I do agree with whomever said the Agatha Christi adaptations are good. )
ReplyDeletebevarcher (at) me (dot) com
I thought Jurassic Park came close to the excitement of the book.
ReplyDeletebigpinelodge at gmail dot com
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. I think this is the first Harry movie that really went with the books for the most part. Loved it.
ReplyDeletemichelle at hookedtobooks dot com
Pride and Prejudice-the one with Colin Firth:)
ReplyDeletek_anon[at]hotmail[dot]co[dot]uk
My favorite books to movie adaptation are The Davinci code and Atonement.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the giveaway!
artgiote at gmail dot com
Goodmorning Kathy and Savita,
ReplyDeleteMy favorite book to movie adaptations are Lord of The Rings, Chronicles of Narnia, Harry Potter and Twilight Saga.
rjofus(at)gmail(dot)com
Great list, I kind of want to read her book just based on her favorite movie adaptations.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite movie based on a book? Stephen King's Misery. I adore the book, but the movie is one of the best King adaptations. Shawshank Redemption and Green Mile are also wonderful.
katetowery(at)gmail(dot)com
Just like Kate above, I think Stephen King's Misery translated very well to film. Some of his other books, not so much, but Misery was great. Oh, Christine was another good one, and Carrie, too...
ReplyDeletecaldellizzi(at)gmail(dot)com
Sounds like a good read! A few of my favorites have been;
ReplyDelete* Harry Potter Series
* The Princess Bride
Anne of Green Gables was always my favorite when I was young. And of course the Lord of the Rings trilogy.
ReplyDeletefindjessyhere at gmail dot com
I really like the latest HP movie and of course Keira Knightley´s Pride and prejudice, but someone has mentioned Fight Club and though I haven´t read the book, the film was fabulous!
ReplyDeleteThank you for the giveaway.
Seesen9(at)gmail(dot)com
The Chronicles of Narnia. And of course, To Kill a Mockingbird.
ReplyDeletekyong_bips[at]yahoo[dot]ca
My all time favorite book to movie adaptation is the Lord of the Rings trilogy. My favorite book and my favorite movie!
ReplyDeletelexie.bookbug(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI loved the Notebook.
ReplyDeletefreda.mans[at]gmail.com
I'd have to say "Atonement"
ReplyDeleteLove & Hugs,
Pam
pk4290(at)comcast(dot)net
My favorite book to movie adaptations, is The Time Travelers Wife. Most books to movies don't come close to the book and it usually bugs me. This one was very very close. Thank you for the chance.
ReplyDeletesteph4575@msn.com
I liked these book-to-movie adaptations: the first Harry Potter and the DaVinci Code.
ReplyDeletejuliecookies(at)gmail.com
All the Harry Potter books/movies and all the Twilight books/movies. Although books are ALWAYS better!! Thanks for the giveaway! :)
ReplyDeleteTina
tinabxtr@yahoo.com
Great question, i have several Pride & Prejudice, Emma, all The Poirot series, Harry Potter, DaVincii Code, Message in a Bottle etc
ReplyDeletebhitwr at gmail dot com
The Notebook.
ReplyDeletepocokat AT gmail DOT com
I loved the Twilight series.
ReplyDeleteGreat Giveaway!
slinkymink@virgilio.it
Lord of the Rings! XD
ReplyDeleteelizabethmueller6ATgmailDOTcom
Guess what? you have an award over at my blog!
The Lord of The Rings.
ReplyDeletesgiden at verizon.net
The Notebook, Harry Potter, and Tuck Everlasting
ReplyDeleteThanks for the giveaway!
adsanders77 at gmail dot com
The Lord of the Rings
ReplyDeletetreerose AT yahoo DOT com
I would say the Harry Potter movies!!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the giveaway!!
jmluker@winco.net
1) P.S. I Love You by Cecelia Ahern (the movie and book were both great)
ReplyDelete2) Harry Potter movies (books were better)
3) Twilight (movie was better than the book)
4) The Lightning Thief (movie was better than the book)
5) Forrest Gump (both movie and book were good)
6) Slumdog Millionaire (both were good in their own way)
sarah.setar@gmail.com
Definitely Lord of the Rings and/or Harry Potter. I can watch both of them over and over...they're just that awesome!
ReplyDeleteBookNoise at gmail dot com
I love the harry potter movie adaptations. They are always spot-on, but they do a decent job! Thanks! seescootread[at]gmail[dot]com
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletehey Kathy, thanks for hosting yet another giveaway! :)
ReplyDeleteMy favorite movie adaptations of books are:
1) Fight Club (by Chuck Palahniuk) - although the book has way more depth,the film adaptation was very apt & entertaining.
2) Lord of the Rings (by J.R.R Tolkein) - the imagery in the book is so beautifully depicted in the movie - the entire series of movies has been amazing.
3) Harry Potter (by JK Rowling) - What needs to be said about this series? Although there is some stuff ommitted in the movies,this movie series has still been largely entertaining, and has depicted Potter's world to perfection.
4) Jurassic Park (by Michael Crichton) - I read this book right before the movie came out,and for days I had dreams about being trapped in a world with dinosaurs - then the movie came out, and those dreams continued for months! lol :P
5) Schindler's List (by Thomas Keneally) - this book was heart breaking and beautiful, but what the movie did with its cinematography was beyond amazing. It took emotions, and gave them color in an otherwise drab world!
All the aforementioned have not just been great books, but were actually turned into great specimens of films on the silver screen. Not only did it relay a good story,but did it with excellent imagery, presented it in cinematographic excellence! :)
Email: Enamoredsoul(at)gmail(dot)com
Twitter: @inluvwithbookz
A Walk to Remember
ReplyDeleteGFC follower
vidishamun@gmail.com
I'd say Harry Potter. I loved the lord of the rings but I couldn't quite connect to it so...Harry wins :)
ReplyDeletealiasgirl at libero dot it
Among the books I've read, I would say :
ReplyDelete- The Lord of the Rings
- Harry Potter (for the movies 5, 6 and 7, because too many details annoy me in the first four!)
- Jurassic Park
Among the books I haven't read :
- The notebook and A walk to remember : two beautiful movies
- Forrest Gump (how don't cry, really ?!)
Thanks for the giveaway ;)
pisisbook[at]hotmail[dot]fr
My favorite has always been Gone With The Wind. Thanks for this chance.
ReplyDeleteayancey(at)dishmail(dot)net
My favorite adaption from book to movie is the Time Travelers Wife. I love the movie. I cried. Please enter me in contest. Tore923@aol.com
ReplyDeleteI have to go with the Chronicles of Narnia. Thanks for the giveaway!
ReplyDeletexxsquigglesxx(at)gmail(dot)com
My favourite adaptation from book to movie would have to be PS I Love You by Cecelia Ahern.
ReplyDeleteshyluck13(at)hotmail(dot)com
My all time favorite is Pride and Prejudice. But I'm also really excited to see the newer version of Jane Eyre coming to theaters.
ReplyDeletegreekpatty13@gmail.com
That would have to be Gone With the Wind! I enjoyed the movie almost as much as I enjoyed the book!
ReplyDeletemittens0831 at aol dot com
I think that my favs are almost all Nicholas Sparks, Dear John, Walk to Remember, and I really enjoyed the V for Vendetta movie as well even though that was created from a graphic novel
ReplyDeletekatie_tp@yahoo.com
I don't know if it's necessarily my favorite, but one I saw recently that I really liked was FLIPPED.
ReplyDeletenowakoski at sbcglobal dot net
I love the harry potter movies. Thank you for having this giveaway.
ReplyDeletechelle2006@aol.com
I like many love the Harry Potter series but I also LOVE The time Traverler's Wife
ReplyDeletePelicanJL[at]hotmail[dot]com
Hm ... that's a hard one ... there have been many ... I think I liked the adaptions (both in Swedish) of "Girl with the Dragon Tattoo" and "Let The Right One In". I also liked the Harry Potter adaptations and the Spiderwick Chronicles adaptation. The Twilight ones were well done, and filmed well - but didn't hold my attention like I wanted, and the Clancy book adaptations have yet to really grip me. So ... after that long prelude, I will go with "Watchmen" - a graphic Novel so counts! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks!
apereiraorama[at]gmail[dot]com
Great list and I see several of my favorites too but changing the movie ending to I AM LEGEND and what it did to the true meaning of the title is what I didn't like about the adaptation.
ReplyDeleteI loved that little twist at the end of book...
Some of my favorite book to movie adaptations includes:
THE JOY LUCK CLUB - I love Amy Tan's book and the mother/daughter stories and the movie kept that intact very well.
THE ENGLISH PATIENT - This was done surprisingly well, I didn't think the movie could have the same dreamy effect as the book but they managed it.
FIRST BLOOD - Even though the movie changed the ending it gave us Rambo!
Thanks for the giveaway.
d.septer at insightbb.com
Thanks for the giveaway! One of my favorite movie adaptations was Nicholas Sparks' 'The Notebook'!
ReplyDeletesophiayunjin at gmail dot com
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI'll have to say my faves are
ReplyDeleteTwilight series by S.Meyer &
Speak by L.H.Anderson
calbizzz_152(@)hotmail(dot)com
Persuasion! LOVEd that movie version
ReplyDeletekissyjensen at gmail dot com
hee hee For some reason, the first thing that came to mind was Cujo!
ReplyDeletenfmgirl AT gmail DOT com
Of course, I love Harry Potter. And I also love Alice in Wonderland.
ReplyDeletegirl23rocks at hotmail dot com
I like The Notebook. captainliss40(at)gmail(dot)com
ReplyDeleteI agree with a number of the books/movies mentioned so in no special order
ReplyDeleteGone with the Wind
To Kill a Mockingbird
Lord of the Rings
2001 - a Space Oddysey
The Green Mile
All the BBC Charles Dickens movies
The Harry Potter stories
The Miyazaki anime adaptions such as Howl's Moving Castle, Soirited Away, Ponyu etc.
Thanks for the giveaway.
Carol T
buddytho {at} gmail DOT com
Such a classic but 'Gone With the Wind' both the novel & movie are superb.
ReplyDeletemarypres@gmail.com
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI loved the Wizard of Oz. It's a classic and I still watch it whenever it comes on. Those are the type of movies I'd be proud to say were part of my childhood. And who couldn't love Toto.
ReplyDeleteLindadao2060@yahoo.com
Fight Club and The Notebook are two of my favorites books...and also movies!
ReplyDeleteMelissa
meland2lilones@yahoo.com
Thank you so much!
ReplyDeleteThis seems like a good read! =)
booksforcompany @gmail.com
My favorite book to movie adaptation is Gigi. The book is by Colette.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the giveaway!
methom@earthlink.net
Silence of the Lambs, Lord of the Rings trilogy, the Harry Potter movies, Sense and Sensibility (w/ Kate Winslet), Howard's End, Pride and Prejudice (w/ Colin Firth)...there are SO many more, but these are some that I love. Thanks for the giveaway!
ReplyDeletetruebookaddictATgmailDOTcom
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSorry Left wrong email. Like i said The Notebook, The Lord of The Rings, The Twilight Series . Oh and Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory ( The older one)
ReplyDeletesinglecountygal34ayahoodotcom
My favorite book-to-movie adaptations:
ReplyDelete. THE NAMESAKE
. THE RUINS
. THE BRIDGES OF MADISON COUNTY
monagarg@yahoo.com
The first Harry Potter - it was magical and convinced me to read the series.
ReplyDeleteeva.s.black[@]gmail[.]com
One of my favorite book to movie adaptations is I Am Number Four. The newest one.:)
ReplyDeletethebookish96[at]gmail[dot]com
The notebook, where the wild things are, & Harry Potter
ReplyDeletetiramisu392 (at) yahoo.com
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI'd say that my favorite book to movie adaptation would be... Let The Right One In. I find it to be just a...masterpiece. Lol.
ReplyDeletealexgoesbwarh@hotmail.com
Pride and Prejudice is my favorite!
ReplyDeletekpuleski at gmail dot com
One of my favorites is The Great Santini.
ReplyDeleteThanks,
Jen
jryder416 at yahoo dot com
the green mile
ReplyDeletespynaert@gmail.com
The Bridges of Madison County is one of my favorites.
ReplyDeletekpbarnett1941[at]aol[dot]com
I loved the Harry Potter series.
ReplyDeleteThanks!
meredithfl at gmail dot com
I love V for Vendetta or William Shakespeare Romeo & Juliet
ReplyDeletechivixen@sbcglobal.net
The Harry Potter movies were pretty good adaptaions
ReplyDeletegevin13{at}gmail{dot}com
Holes was a pretty good adaptation
ReplyDeletemearley1979 at gmail dot com
"The General's Daughter" by Nelson DeMille. Loved them!
ReplyDeleteThe top three that come to mind is any of the Harry Potter books, any of the Twilight books, "The Notebook", "Gone with the Wind", any of the "Lord of the Rings", and "Jurassic Park". Okay, that's way more than three but I could go on and on and on...
ReplyDeleteBornajhawkATaolDOTcom
My favourite adaptation was "Charlie St. Cloud"
ReplyDeletepetra_socaciu@yahoo.com
I like the Jurassic Park adaptation!
ReplyDeleteskkorman AT bellsouth DOT net
Fight Club was a great adaptation of the book.
ReplyDeletemethirteenATyahooDOTcom
I will have to choose the Lord of the Rings but there are so many great ones that it's hard to pick one:-)
ReplyDeleteThank you for this giveaway and for making it international.
forceofstars(at)yahoo(dot)dk
The Outsiders, The Notebook, and The Ramona movie.
ReplyDeletenancyecdavis AT bellsouth DOT net
I would have to say Lovely Bones was my favorite there are many though
ReplyDeletepattifritz2000 at yahoo dot com
thanks bunches
Chronicles of Narnia - the old ones.
ReplyDeleteags0104 at gmail dot com